You've Won! (But Have You Really?) How to Spot Sweepstakes and Lottery Scams

Imagine opening your email to find a message congratulating you on winning $2.5 million in a sweepstakes you don't remember entering. Your heart races with excitement—until they mention you need to pay a small "processing fee" of $500 to claim your prize. Something doesn't feel right, but the message looks official, complete with logos and legal-sounding language. Should you pay the fee?

If you've ever faced this situation—or worry you might—you're not alone. Sweepstakes and lottery scams are among the most common frauds targeting seniors, and they can happen any time of year. However, they surge dramatically during the holiday season when legitimate retailers run genuine contests and our mailboxes overflow with special offers.

Why This Matters to You

Scammers love sweepstakes schemes because they play on our natural excitement about winning. They know that many of us enter legitimate contests, especially during the holidays when stores offer special promotions. These criminals also understand that seniors often have retirement savings they've worked hard to build—making them prime targets.

According to the Federal Trade Commission, Americans lose over $100 million annually to prize and lottery scams. What makes these scams particularly cruel is that victims often send money multiple times, convinced their big win is just one more payment away.

But here's the empowering truth: once you know what to look for, these scams are surprisingly easy to spot. The "fees" or "taxes" requirement is actually your biggest clue that something's wrong—and in this guide, you'll learn exactly why.

What You'll Learn

In this comprehensive guide, you'll discover:

• The golden rule that instantly reveals fake prize notifications
• Four common ways scammers contact potential victims
• Real warning signs from actual sweepstakes scam attempts
• Why legitimate sweepstakes never work the way scammers claim
• Exactly what to do if you're contacted about a "prize"
• How to protect yourself and your loved ones year-round

The Golden Rule of Legitimate Prizes

Let's start with the single most important fact about real sweepstakes and lottery winnings:

You never have to pay money to collect legitimate prize winnings. Ever.‍

This is true whether you won $50 or $50 million. Legitimate companies and organizations that award prizes will never ask you to:

• Pay processing fees, handling charges, or administrative costs
• Send money for taxes before receiving your winnings
• Wire money or send gift cards to claim your prize
• Provide bank account information to "deposit" your winnings
• Pay for shipping or delivery of your prize

If someone asks for any payment before you receive a prize, it's a scam. No exceptions.

How Scammers Make Contact

Sweepstakes scammers are creative in how they reach potential victims. During the holiday season especially, they take advantage of the increased volume of legitimate promotional mail and calls. Here are the four most common methods:

Phone Calls

You receive an excited call from someone claiming to represent Publishers Clearing House, a well-known retailer, or even a government lottery agency. They'll often use official-sounding titles like "Prize Distribution Center" or "Winners Notification Department." The caller might know some personal details about you, making the call seem more legitimate. They'll create urgency, saying you must act within hours to claim your prize.

Emails

These messages often feature professional-looking logos and graphics from real companies. The subject line shouts "WINNER!" or "Congratulations!" Inside, you'll find detailed instructions about claiming your prize—which always includes sending money first. Some emails even include fake legal disclaimers and privacy policies to appear more authentic.

Text Messages

A text arrives announcing you've won a gift card, vacation package, or cash prize from a store or website you've actually used. The message includes a link to claim your prize, which leads to a fake website designed to steal your personal information or request payment.

Physical Mail

Official-looking letters arrive with check-like documents, often for small amounts like $3,000 to $5,000. Instructions tell you to deposit the check and wire a portion back for "taxes" or "fees." The check will initially appear to clear in your bank account, but it's counterfeit—and you'll be responsible for the full amount when the fraud is discovered days or weeks later.

Red Flags That Reveal the Scam

Beyond the fundamental rule about never paying to collect winnings, watch for these warning signs:

You Don't Remember Entering

Most legitimate sweepstakes require you to enter—you don't automatically win prizes from companies you've never heard of. If you can't remember entering a contest, you probably didn't. Think of it like this: you wouldn't suddenly receive a college diploma from a school you never attended. The same logic applies to prizes.

Pressure to Act Immediately

Scammers create artificial urgency: "You must respond within 24 hours or forfeit your prize!" Legitimate prize administrators understand that winners need time to verify the award and make arrangements. They won't threaten to give your winnings to someone else if you don't wire money by midnight.

Requests for Secrecy

If someone tells you to keep your "winnings" secret—even from family members, your bank, or financial advisors—that's a massive red flag. Scammers know that if you discuss the situation with someone you trust, they'll likely talk you out of sending money. Real prize organizations never ask winners to keep quiet.

Payment Method Requests

Any request to pay via wire transfer, gift cards, cryptocurrency, or cash sent by mail is guaranteed to be a scam. These payment methods are nearly impossible to trace or reverse. Think about it: legitimate companies accept normal payment methods like credit cards because they have nothing to hide.

Poor Grammar or Spelling

While not always present, many scam notifications contain obvious spelling errors, awkward phrasing, or grammatical mistakes. A legitimate major corporation or government agency wouldn't send official prize notifications riddled with typos.

What About Taxes on Real Winnings?

You might wonder, "Don't I have to pay taxes on prizes?" The answer is yes—but not the way scammers claim.

When you win a legitimate prize worth $600 or more, the prize administrator will send you IRS Form W-2G or 1099-MISC reporting the winnings. You'll pay taxes when you file your annual tax return, just like you would on other income. Sometimes, if you win a very large prize, the organization might withhold a percentage for federal taxes before sending your winnings—but you never send them money.

Here's a helpful comparison: imagine your employer called and said, "You got a raise! Just send us $500 and we'll add it to your next paycheck." That would be absurd. Prize winnings work the same way.

How to Respond When Contacted

If you receive a prize notification, here's exactly what to do:

Step 1: Don't Respond Immediately‍

Take a breath and resist the excitement or pressure. Legitimate prizes will still be there tomorrow.

‍Step 2: Verify Independently‍

Don't use contact information provided in the notification. Instead, look up the company's official website or phone number yourself through a web search or phone directory. Call them directly and ask about the prize using any confirmation numbers mentioned in the notification.

‍Step 3: Research the Legitimacy‍

Search online for the prize name plus the word "scam." For example, search "Publishers Clearing House $2 million scam" or the specific wording from your notification. You'll often find reports from others who received the same fraudulent message.

Step 4: Talk to Someone You Trust‍

Despite what the notification might say, discuss it with a family member, friend, or your financial advisor. A fresh perspective often reveals red flags you might have missed in the excitement.

‍Step 5: Report the Scam‍

Report the attempted scam to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state's attorney general office. If the scammer claimed to represent a specific company, report it to that company as well.

Special Holiday Season Awareness

During the holidays, when retailers run legitimate promotional contests and our mail volume increases, sweepstakes scams become even more prevalent. Scammers know you're more likely to believe you won something during this time of year.

Be especially cautious of:

• "Black Friday Winner" or "Holiday Sweepstakes" notifications
• Fake gift card winnings from stores where you actually shop
• Bogus "12 Days of Christmas" prize announcements
• New Year's "lucky winner" schemes
• Notifications that arrive just after major shopping events

The increased holiday mail and promotional activity provides perfect cover for scammers. That's why the verification steps above are so important—take the time to confirm every prize notification, even during busy holiday weeks.

Protecting Your Loved Ones

Now that you know how to protect yourself, consider sharing this knowledge. Many seniors fall victim to these scams because they simply don't know the warning signs. You can help by:

• Sharing this information with friends who might be vulnerable
• Discussing sweepstakes scams at community gatherings or social groups
• Offering to help a friend verify a prize notification they've received
• Reminding family members of the golden rule: never pay to collect winnings

Sometimes the best protection for a friend is a simple conversation: "Did you know legitimate prizes never require payment? If anyone asks you to send money to collect winnings, it's always a scam."

Your Action Plan

You now have the knowledge to confidently identify sweepstakes and lottery scams. Remember these key points:

• Never pay money to collect any prize—no fees, taxes, or charges
• Verify all prize notifications independently before responding
• Recognize pressure tactics and requests for secrecy as red flags
• Report suspected scams to protect others

The next time you receive an exciting "winner" notification, you'll know exactly how to evaluate it. You'll feel confident asking the right questions and taking the proper verification steps. And if it turns out to be a scam, you'll have the satisfaction of knowing you outsmarted the criminals.

Continue Your Protection Journey

Understanding sweepstakes scams is an important step in protecting yourself online and offline. At Cyber Smart Seniors, we're dedicated to giving you the knowledge and tools to navigate today's world with confidence.

Want to strengthen your defenses even further? Explore our comprehensive guides on related topics like phone scam recognition, email safety verification, and financial fraud prevention. Each guide builds on the skills you're developing, creating a complete protection strategy tailored specifically for seniors.

Remember, staying safe isn't about living in fear—it's about living with confidence, armed with the right knowledge. You've taken an important step today, and we're here to support you every step of the way.

Stay smart, stay safe, and enjoy the genuine good things that come your way—including real prizes, if you're lucky enough to win them legitimately!

_{- - - -}

_{Copyright © 2025 Cyber Smart Seniors. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law.}